What's a good gift for valentines day for a guy? We've been together 4 four months and really like each other.

He's kind of afraid of love. But he really likes me and told me he feels like he's in love. He's also kind of a simple guy...extravagant things don't impress him like they impress other people...he's more moved by the thought. At Christmas I baked him cookies and got him a necklace and a nice card.. then we watched a movie afterward. So what do i do now??